(TBS #14) Is it Safe to Exercise When you have Thyroid Problems?
Is it dangerous to exercise if you have thyroid disease?
How much is "too much" exercise?
Will exercise help you lose weight or will it hurt your metabolism?
All of these questions and more will be answered in this post which is all about exercise and thyroid problems.
You will learn the best types of exercises, how much you should be exercising and the best way to lose weight.
Let's jump in:
Understanding Metabolism, Exercise and Caloric Burn
We really can't have a discussion about exercise without at least touching on the idea of metabolism.
The term metabolism is often used when referring to the number of calories that your body burns throughout the day.
It's also commonly referred to as resting energy expenditure (REE) and resting metabolic rate (RMR) (1).
And it is your metabolism which accounts for the largest number of calories that you burn each and every day (not the how much you exercise!).
Your metabolism is responsible for around 50 to 90% of the total amount of calories that you burn (2) each day.
Your body uses this much energy because it must keep you alive by beating your heart, helping you think, helping to digest your food and so on.
These things MUST happen every single day and they are very energy intensive (meaning it requires a lot of energy).
So if around 70% (I'm taking an average between 50 and 90% here) of the calories you burn each day is from your metabolism, what accounts for the other 30%?
That other 30% really depends on your activity level and it can change from day to day (3) (which alters your appetite!).
Activities such as stress, extra walking, going shopping, doing chores around the house and so on all require more energy and these factors account for the other 30%.
It may be helpful to look at a 2,000 calorie per day example to drive this information home.
Let's assume that you burn 2,000 calories per day (on average).
Using the figures above we know that about 70% of the calories that you burn each day will be from your metabolism.
This accounts for around 1,400 calories per day.
Just keep this information in the back of your head, we will come back to it later.
The remaining 30% of the calories that you burn comes from other sources and your activity level which accounts for 600 calories per day.
So, when most people want to lose weight they think they can burn more calories simply by increasing the amount that they exercise (5).
But let's consider another example here.
What if your thyroid is sub-optimal and you aren't being treated appropriately?
If your thyroid is responsible for around 50% of your metabolism and your thyroid is not functioning well that means you may be losing out on an extra 400 calories per day from a damaged metabolism!
It may be far easier to simply address your thyroid problem to help increase the number of calories you burn by an extra 400 per day because trying to burn an extra 400 calories per day would take a significant amount of time through exercise.
Does that mean you should avoid exercise?
Not by a long shot!
But it does mean you may want to ensure that your thyroid is working properly before you jump into serious work out routines.
Should you Exercise if you have Thyroid Issues?
It may sound like I'm discounting the benefit of exercise and I don't want that to be the case.
It's also incredibly helpful if you have thyroid disease and can help manage your hormones.
So the answer to the question as to whether or not you should exercise is a definite YES.
But what you need to understand is the amount and type of exercise that you use will vary from individual to individual.
It also means that there isn't one single "best" exercise routine that you HAVE to do.
Exercising is beneficial to your body (and your thyroid) because it can help improve your metabolism.
It does this by increasing the activity and size of your muscles.
And it takes a considerable amount of calories to keep your muscles happy and active (7).
Increasing muscle mass will help you improve the overall amount of calories that you burn in that 70% portion.
In addition, exercising also has the benefit of increasing the number of calories that you burn day to day.
This will help increase the amount of calories that you burn in the 30% portion.
Another point worth mentioning has to do with your goal when you exercise.
If you are like most people you probably only consider exercising as a means to manage your weight.
And this is the wrong way to look at it.
You want to exercise because it will help your body manage your hormones, manage the flow of calories and which tissues utilize those calories and as a way to improve your muscle mass.
Many of these things may help with weight loss, but that shouldn't be your goal!
As you exercise more and more, you may notice that your muscle mass increases accordingly.
This increase in muscle mass is often associated with a decrease in fat mass (this is a good thing) but it may keep your weight "neutral" or the same.
And this is NOT a bad thing.
Your goal when losing weight should be to lose fat mass, and that's exactly what exercise will do.
Exercise and the Stress it Causes to Your Body (And your Adrenals)
One of the questions I get asked from people on this blog has to do with adrenal function and exercise.
Many patients with hypothyroidism also happen to suffer from the symptoms associated with "adrenal fatigue" and many of these patients also have abnormal or sub-optimal serum cortisol levels.
If you fall into this category is it still safe to exercise?
You have to consider that exercise is a stressful event for your body (8).
The whole goal of exercise is to break down the body slightly while allowing it enough time to heal so it grows back stronger than it was before.
When you keep this in mind it's easy to understand that true exercise is not something that you want to do every single day.
If you do not allow your body sufficient time to heal then your exercise may just be adding more and more stress to your body (this is a bad thing!).
This element of stress can compound other sources of stress such as lack of sleep, a poor diet, social stressors and more.
The net result?
More stress to your body and the worsening of your symptoms such as fatigue, weight gain, crashes in the midday and more.
This means, contrary to popular belief, that doing spin classes for 1 hour each day may not be the best way for you to lose weight and feel better!
So what are you supposed to do?
You should aim to match the intensity of your exercise routine to your personalized energy level.
By matching the intensity of your workouts to your energy level you can stay within the "optimal" range of exercise without risking damage to other hormones.
As you match your intensity to your energy level you will find that your energy level IMPROVES, your fatigue REDUCES and you start to feel better overall.
I will go over how to match this in a bit but first I want to focus on types of exercises that you can (and should) be doing.
Is there a "Best" Type of Exercise if you have Thyroid Problems?
There isn't a single "best" type of exercise for your thyroid.
There also isn't an exercise that will improve your thyroid function!
But, there are several types of exercises that would be considered "approved" and helpful if you have a thyroid problem.
In general, you want to look at two basic types of exercises:
#1. High intensity interval training.
Exercises that fit into this category include:
- Circuit training (body weight)
- Circuit training (9) (weight training with resistance)
- Strength training
- Virtually any exercise can provide this benefit if taken to the extreme
#2. And low intensity exercise.
Exercises that fit into this category include:
- Household chores
How Often Should you Exercise?
Most people probably know the various types of exercises available to them, but they struggle when it comes to frequency.
Meaning, how often should you be exercising?
How often should you do high intensity interval training and/or low intensity training?
The answer is actually quite simple:
You'll know if you are exercising at a sufficient rate if you feel energized after you exercise.
Exercising should lift you up, it should increase your energy and it should make you feel good.
If you are exercising and you find that you are wiped out for several days afterward then that is a sign that you are over exercising!
You will want to avoid this behavior as much as possible because it can lead to more metabolic damage in the long run.
If you are new to thyroid related issues and you want to get started then the goal should be to start low and slow.
Starting with high intensity exercise for 15 minutes 1-2x per week is usually a safe bet.
As you progress, and as you listen to your body, you can increase both the duration and frequency with which you exercise.
Something like 15-20 minutes of high intensity interval training 2-3x per week usually works very well for most people.
This can be supplemented with daily low intensity activities.
As you determine which exercises you should be doing it's worth pointing out that you should put preference on those types of exercises which help to build muscle mass in your body.
The more muscle mass you have the higher your metabolism will be.
You can do this by focusing on the major muscle groups in your body:
Focusing on these muscle groups will give you the biggest "bang for your buck" so to speak.
If you focus on weight training just make sure that you do not exercise muscle groups which are already sore from previous exercise regimens.
Adding Intermittent Fasting & Sauna to Your Exercise Routine
Lastly, you can also supplement your exercise routine with a couple of other therapies which have the capacity to enhance your results.
It may be tempting to take pre-work out boosters, thermogenics or caffeine laced supplements but do your best to avoid these supplements if you have thyroid issues.
They can actually make your fatigue worse in the long run by putting excess stress on your body as you exercise.
As you avoid these therapies you can also consider adding some others.
Specifically sauna therapy and/or intermittent fasting.
As always, proceed with caution if you have never tried these therapies before.
They certainly have the ability to improve your results but they also may cause side effects if you aren't sure how much your body can manage.
Exercising with thyroid issues is an important and complex topic!
Exercising can help benefit your body, help with your weight, manage your metabolism and more.
But in order to get these benefits, your exercise routine must be targeted to your body.
You can do this by listening to your body.
If you aren't sure where to start you may find benefit in looking for a functionally minded health coach to help guide you along the way.
Now I want to hear from you:
Are you struggling with exercise as a thyroid patient?
Have you been able to realize any benefits from your workout routine?
What workouts have helped you? Which have not?
Leave your comments or questions below!
References (Click to Expand)