5

High TSH Symptoms, Causes & What it Means

Have you been told, or are you suspicious, that you have a high TSH?

If so there are many things you want to consider before pursuing treatment.

While your TSH is important for assessing thyroid function it's certainly not the only test, or the best way, to identify thyroid disease. 

We are going to take an updated, scientific dive into TSH including what a high TSH means, what kind of symptoms are associated with this condition and the top 5 causes... 

More...

What does your TSH really mean?

Many physicians consider TSH to be the most accurate marker of thyroid status in your body. 

With that in mind it makes sense to talk about what it actually does in your body. 

TSH stands for thyroid stimulating hormone and it is a hormone secreted from your pituitary gland. 

Thyroid physiology is quite complex but we can break it down to an easy to understand sequence:

Your hypothalamus (part of your brain) pumps out a hormone called TRH (thyrotropin releasing hormone). 

TSH feedback loop

TRH then acts on your pituitary gland (another portion of your brain) to stimulate the release of TSH (thyroid stimulating hormone). 

TSH then enters your bloodstream and lands on receptors directly on your thyroid gland which then causes the release of thyroid hormones - T3 and T4. 

T3 and T4 then enter the bloodstream and target specific cells in the body (almost every cell has a thyroid receptor) to alter genetic transcription, increase energy production and so forth. 

This complex system is regulated at several steps and one step that we use to assess the stability of this entire system is the serum concentration of TSH. 

This isn't the best marker of thyroid function by itself, but it can give you a quick idea of what is happening in the body. 

So what does a high TSH actually mean?

An elevation in TSH is an indicator that the system is not working properly, and in this case it means that thyroid function in the serum (T3 and T4) is low. 

Low levels of T3 and T4 circulate back up to the pituitary gland which tells the body that not enough thyroid hormone is being produced. 

Your pituitary gland compensates by increasing TSH levels in the serum because it is trying to tell your thyroid gland to produce more thyroid hormone. 

Hopefully this is making sense. 

It can be confusing because a high TSH level actually means that there is not ENOUGH thyroid hormone in the blood and this condition is known as hypothyroidism. 

Hypothyroidism = low thyroid function = sluggish thyroid = low T3 and T4 levels of thyroid hormone in the blood = high TSH (all of these terms are ways to describe the same condition)

The exact opposite is true when the TSH is low. 

A low TSH is an indicator that your body has enough T3 and T4 in the body and so your pituitary responds by reducing the production of TSH from the pituitary gland. 

Hyperthyroidism = excessive thyroid production = high T3 and/or T4 levels of thyroid hormone in the blood = low TSH

This isn't the complete picture because certain medications can actually reduce TSH but still leave T3 and T4 levels low in the body, but it gives you a general idea of what is actually happening in the body and what your TSH actually stands for. 

So how do Doctors use TSH in patients?

TSH is primarily used as a marker of thyroid hormone status in the entire body. 

Checking your TSH can be used as a quick measure to determine if your thyroid is functioning properly or not. 

A high TSH (defined below) tells your Doctor that your thyroid is not working properly which means that you may need the use of thyroid hormone medications to increase and normalize thyroid function. 

After starting thyroid medication (if necessary) the TSH can be used to "track" your progress. 

As you take thyroid medication your TSH should be reduced back to the "normal" range. 

As this occurs you are said to once again become "euthyroid". 

This is how everything is supposed to work, but is it really that easy?

This is where Doctors and patients tend to disagree

Even though you can "normalize" the TSH with thyroid medications, many of the symptoms of hypothyroidism may actually still persist. 

This, along with many studies, may indicate that TSH may not be the best marker for thyroid function in the body

We will discuss more of that below, but for now let's discuss what kind of symptoms you may experience if your TSH is elevated. 

High TSH Symptoms

As your TSH increases it is a sign that circulating levels of thyroid hormones are dropping. 

Therefore, the symptoms associated with high TSH levels present as the symptoms of hypothyroidism. 

Symptoms do not stem from the TSH itself, but from the lack of circulating T3 and T4 and their influence on your cells.

In addition, symptom severity is dependent, at least somewhat, on the degree of elevation of TSH. 

Higher levels of TSH, those greater than  

The degree of elevation of your TSH will also help determine the severity of your symptoms. 

People who have a TSH of 5.0 will likely experience symptoms that aren't quite as severe as someone who has a TSH of 7.0 or higher. 

You can find a list of the symptoms that one might experience with a high TSH below: 

  • Weight gain or difficulty losing weight (the degree of weight gain and inability to lose weight depends on the severity of thyroid lab studies)
  • Fatigue or decreased energy
  • Insomnia or inability to sleep
  • Changes to menstrual cycle or changes to sex hormones (reduced testosterone in both men and women and changes to progesterone/estradiol in women)
  • Drop in body temperature - cold hands/feet
  • Slower than normal metabolism
  • Changes to skin that include dry or cracking of the skin
  • Changes to hair, skin and nails quality and texture - brittle hair, dry hair, hair loss, etc.
  • Slowing down of the intestines which manifests as constipation or acid reflux
  • Mental changes to include depression, anxiety, poor concentration or poor memory
  • Swelling of the face or extremities (puffy eyes)

Why are symptoms important?

Symptoms reduction, along with TSH, can also be used as a marker to determine if therapy or treatment is working. 

You can find a more complete list of thyroid symptoms that women may experience in this post, and a complete list of thyroid symptoms that men experience in this post

Definition of a "High" TSH (Reference Ranges)

So what defines a "high" TSH?

By definition the standard reference range for TSH is anywhere between 0.30 to 5.0 uIU/mL. 

If your TSH is higher than 5.0 then the lab will flag you as "high" and you may experience the symptoms listed above. 

You can see a clear example of this below: 

high TSH and hypothyroidism

The reference range in this example is 0.3 to 5.00 uIU/ml and the result is 7.024. 

Having said all of this, there's actually a good case to make that you can still have a "high" TSH but still be inside of the reference range. 

So how do we get there?

Well, newer studies have shed light on the fact that some of the original tests that helped determine our "standard normal" TSH values may have not have been full of "healthy" people. 

When you are being compared to some standard you want to make sure that the standard you are being compared to is actually healthy!

It doesn't make sense to compare your TSH as a 25 year old to that of a 86 year old

Using this logic some newer studies have suggested that a more "normal" TSH reference range is somewhere between 1.0 and 2.5 uIU/ml and anything higher than 2.5 is considered "high"

With this logic you can have a "high" TSH anywhere between 2.5 and 5.5, even though it technically falls within the "normal" range: 

Abnormal TSH kathy

In addition, other studies have suggested we use the African American population as the standard for TSH testing because they have one of the lowest rates of autoimmune disease compared to other populations and their TSH is somewhere around 1.0. 

It's important to realize that many physicians are not aware of these studies or these concepts so they may use the "standard" laboratory reference range instead of these newer guidelines. 

TSH levels in various populations

5 Causes of High TSH

Having a high TSH is never normal. 

An elevated TSH (as defined by the reference ranges listed above) is an indication that your body is working overtime to try and increase the amount of thyroid hormone that it can produce. 

In most cases your TSH is simply a warning sign that indicates your body is under stress and increased pressure. 

While knowing that your TSH is elevated is important, your TSH itself does not tell you WHY it is increased. 

That's why it's important to understand the potential causes because each of these causes has a different treatment. 

#1. Hashimoto's Thyroiditis

Probably the most common cause of slightly elevated and high TSH levels is an autoimmune disease known as Hashimoto's Thyroiditis. 

It is estimated that anywhere between 50% and 90% of all cases of hypothyroidism may be caused by this condition in the United States. 

Hashimoto's thyroiditis is a condition where your body begins to attack its own thyroid gland, through an autoimmune process, which results in long term and potentially permanent damage to your thyroid gland over time

As your thyroid gland becomes damaged the amount of thyroid hormone it produces will be reduced over time. 

As this happens your pituitary compensates by increasing TSH levels slowly over time. 

In a sense it's like trying to squeeze water out of a rock. 

How can your thyroid gland produce thyroid hormone if it is permanently damaged?

It can't. 

The good news is that diagnosing Hashimoto's thyroiditis is not very difficult and can be assessed by checking for thyroid antibodies in the serum. 

The presence of clinical thyroid damage (symptoms) combined with elevated antibodies is sufficient to diagnose the disease. 

Your Doctor should know to check for the following antibodies:

If they are contributing to your TSH then your labs may look something like the example listed below: 

Hashimotos thyroiditis with high TPO antibodies

Identifying that you have Hashimoto's is important because it means you may be able to influence the course of the disease and reduce the autoimmune damage if you take steps as soon as possible. 

Note, though, that in some cases by the time the diagnosis is made it may be too late - there may already be permanent damage to your thyroid gland, especially if the autoimmune process has been going on for decades. 

You can learn more about treating, identifying and managing Hashimoto's in this post

#2. Iodine Deficiency

While overt iodine deficiency is no longer a huge issue in the United States, many people may still have what I refer to as "sub optimal" iodine levels. 

The main method that we get iodine is through our diets, but unfortunately many factors may be influencing how much we actually get. 

For starters many people simply aren't consuming enough iodine because they don't consume sea vegetables regularly. 

This is worsened by the fact that the iodine concentration in the soil is dropping as well, so foods that would normally contain iodine may vary in their concentration. 

In addition, other factors such as the lack of utilization (from goitrogens) in certain foods may limit the activity of iodine that you do consume. 

Taking this one step further...

Studies have shown that the average person should be consuming 150 ug of iodine per day (up to 250-290 if you are lactating or pregnant), while other studies show that the average consumption varies between 120-130 ug per day

recommended iodine consumption in the US for pregnant women

You can compare this to the 1970's where the average consumption of iodine was up to 294 ug/day. 

iodine consumption in the US

Putting all this together you can make a case that many people simply may not be getting sufficient iodine even though we live in an iodine "replete" environment. 

How does this impact TSH?

Iodine is required for the production of thyroid hormone in your body

Therefore, low iodine will result in low circulating thyroid hormone in the serum. 

This will trigger a feedback loop which will result in an increase in TSH from your pituitary. 

Low iodine = high TSH. 

The good news is that replacing iodine through dietary means will rapidly result in improvement in your thyroid function. 

You can learn more about using iodine safely and correctly in this detailed guide

#3. Obesity & Metabolic Damage

Most people assume that hypothyroidism (low thyroid function) causes obesity, but what they don't realize is that obesity can actually decrease thyroid function as well. 

The cause vs effect has not been settled but we will most likely find that while hypothyroidism can cause obesity, obesity can also reduce thyroid function and increase TSH. 

Why does this matter?

For starters it means that if obesity is the cause of low thyroid function (and therefore an elevated TSH) it means that if you lose weight you will improve your thyroid status. 

And this is what studies have shown. 

As you lose weight TSH tends to drop and FT3 and FT4 levels tend to normalize

Another important implication of the obesity-thyroid connection is that due to the widespread increase in obesity we may need to alter TSH reference ranges

Our understand of obesity and thyroid function is that obesity is the RESULT of hypothyroidism. 

But if obesity causes hypothyroidism then that means we need to create a "normal" TSH based on the reference ranges of people that have a normal body weight and who do NOT have Hashimoto's thyroiditis. 

This may impact our definition of the "ideal" or "normal" TSH. 

Moral of the story?

Obesity, weight gain and metabolic damage may all potentially increase your TSH and lead to hypothyroidism. 

#4. Stress & Increased Cortisol

Another important cause of high TSH is due to stress and increased cortisol. 

Cortisol is considered our stress hormone which is released to help our body "tolerate" excessively stressful situations. 

Stressful situations range from lack of sleep to social pressure from jobs and back to the food we put in our body. 

The idea here is that all of these factors influence this stress hormone and may result in chronic elevations in serum cortisol. 

High cortisol is positively correlated with TSH levels in the serum

This means that as cortisol increases so too does TSH. 

What isn't clear is whether or not this relationship is physiologic or pathologic. 

In my experience I tend to lean more to the pathologic side as patients with both high TSH and high cortisol exhibit higher rates of depression, anxiety and poor cognitive function. 

These symptoms lead me to believe that stress, excessive stress which is chronic in nature, most likely results in an increased TSH which reduces thyroid function in the body. 

The treatment for this condition is to focus on limiting the impact that stress has on your physiology by taking targeted supplements and practicing specific therapies. 

You can learn more about addressing cortisol to improve thyroid function here

#5. Thyroidectomy (Partial or Complete) & RAI

Next up is really any condition that results in damage or removal of your thyroid gland. 

It makes sense that if you damage your thyroid gland or completely remove it that you won't be producing as much thyroid hormone as you were before. 

Most people who undergo complete thyroidectomy (meaning complete removal of their thyroid gland) are given thyroid medication right away. 

The same is not necessarily true for those who have only had a portion or partial thyroidectomy (partial removal of their thyroid gland). 

Patients who undergo RAI or radioactive iodine ablation therapy may also still have some thyroid gland function, but this function may not be sufficient to provide adequate thyroid hormone to the entire body. 

In both cases these patients may still have somewhat "normal" thyroid lab studies but tend to present with MANY of the symptoms of hypothyroidism. 

The bottom line?

Damage to your thyroid gland or removal of your thyroid gland (even part of it) may result in an increase in TSH levels. 

The treatment for patients in cases such as these is the replacement of thyroid hormone with thyroid hormone medication. 

Is it Possible to Have a High TSH and Normal T3 & T4? 

Yes!

In some cases the serum T3 and T4 levels can be relatively preserved despite elevation in TSH levels. 

Some people assume this is a reactive response but you must realize that serum concentrations of thyroid hormone do not necessarily reflect tissue levels of thyroid hormone. 

What's important is not the serum concentration but the amount of thyroid hormone that enters the cells and activates genetic transcription. 

TSH reflects the tissue concentration of the pituitary gland, but it does not reflect the concentration of say your liver. 

We can use SHBG as an indirect marker for assessing the concentration of thyroid function in the liver and this can actually be used as a somewhat sensitive marker for tissue levels elsewhere in the body. 

You can learn more about using the SHBG for this purpose in this guide

Just realize for now that in order to get a "complete" picture of thyroid function in the body, you should evaluate TSH in the presence of other thyroid lab studies such as free T3, total T3, free T4, sex hormone binding globulin and of course thyroid antibodies. 

Final Thoughts

A high TSH level may indicate that you have sub-optimal levels of circulating thyroid hormone in your body. 

This condition is known as hypothyroidism and presents with MANY diverse symptoms. 

If you find that you have high TSH then your next step should be to look into the potential causes of the disease and treat that if possible. 

You will also want to consider if thyroid medication is right for you or if taking a more conservative approach may be the best fit. 

When evaluating TSH make sure that you are evaluated with the "optimal" level in mind and not the standard laboratory reference range. 

Now I want to hear from you:

Is your TSH high? 

If so, have you been able to find appropriate treatment?

If not, why not? 

Leave your comments below! 

Westin Childs
 

I’m Dr. Childs and I write these posts. I’m a physician that specializes helping patients lose weight, have more energy and FEEL better. My practice focuses on hormone imbalances, thyroid issues and weight loss resistance. My goal is to provide the BEST information out there on the internet that is both actionable and trustworthy. Get my free 3 day meal plan here. You can also find more about my personal journey back to health here.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 5 comments